Tim Bökemeier, Insurance expert

In July 2026, Debeka disclosed what its most expensive treatment cases cost in 2025. The highest single bill was almost €372,000, caused by a complication related to a spinal disease.

In total, the insurer paid around €7.2 billion in health insurance benefits in 2025. For context: Debeka is the largest private health insurer in Germany. More than five million people have health insurance there, around 2.5 million of them with comprehensive private cover.

The most expensive single cases of 2025

CaseAmount billed
Complication of a spinal diseasealmost €372,000
Heart attackmore than €371,000
Mycosis fungoides, a rare form of cancermore than €323,000
Cases of more than €300,000 eacheight in the whole year

These amounts come from an internal analysis by Debeka. They are not an industry average and cannot be projected onto private health insurance as a whole.

The more interesting figure lies in everyday care

Six-figure bills are rare. Eight cases among more than five million insured people are statistically almost negligible, and no plan decision should be based on them.

The figure that really affects everyone is given by Debeka’s chief executive Thomas Brahm, using the example of an appendectomy. In the Koblenz area, the cost of this routine operation doubled within five years, from around €3,500 to almost €7,000.

Doubling in five years corresponds to a cost increase of about 15 percent a year. This is a single regional value and not a national statistic. But the order of magnitude shows where premium development really comes from: from everyday medicine and not from the exceptional cases.

Why costs are rising

Brahm calls it medical inflation. Spending on treatments, medicines and care rises faster than costs in other areas of life. Several drivers are at work at the same time:

  • higher hospital and staff costs
  • rising prices for medicines and medical aids
  • new forms of therapy that are more effective and at the same time much more expensive
  • demographic change and with it more treatment cases
  • general price development in the healthcare sector

The industry figure supports this picture. In 2025, private health insurance paid a total of €42.1 billion in benefits, an increase of 7.1 percent on the previous year. Health insurance alone accounted for €39.0 billion, plus 6.9 percent.

What this means for your premium

Premium adjustments in private health insurance are often read as the pricing policy of the insurers. The figures show a different picture.

An insurer may not raise the premium freely. An adjustment is only triggered when a threshold set by law is exceeded, either for insurance benefits or for mortality rates. Then the premium must be recalculated, and for the entire remaining term of the contract. An independent trustee checks the result.

Rising treatment costs therefore inevitably end up in the premium. This applies to every insurer and every plan. How strongly depends on how cautiously the original calculation was made.

The consequence for your choice of plan

From our advisory practice, this is the point where most mistakes happen. If you choose a plan by today’s monthly premium, you buy a snapshot in a market whose costs have been rising significantly for years.

Three criteria carry more weight over the term:

CriterionWhy it counts
Premium stability in the historyshows how cautiously the insurer calculated. A strikingly low entry premium catches up with the calculation later.
How binding the benefit promises arewith a bill of more than €300,000, the policy wording decides, not the advertising brochure.
Financial strength of the insurerthe ageing reserves must absorb the rise in costs in old age.

The other side belongs to an honest assessment. Part of these costs arises because modern methods make treatments possible that did not exist ten years ago. The case of more than €371,000 after a heart attack is also the bill for the patient having survived.

What you can do now

  • Do not measure your own plan by its current premium, but by its premium development over the past ten years.
  • In the event of a premium adjustment, first check an internal plan change under § 204 VVG. Your ageing reserves are kept.
  • Do the math before you switch to another insurer. A lower entry premium with another insurer costs you most of the reserves you have built up.
  • Weigh the deductible against your own actual use, not against the premium savings alone.

Conclusion

The Debeka figures are no argument against private health insurance. They are evidence of what the premium is used for: €7.2 billion in benefits, and in an extreme case almost €372,000 for a single insured person.

For your own decision, this leads to a simple standard. A plan does not have to be cheap today. It has to be affordable in twenty years and still pay out then. If you are unsure how your own contract stands in this respect, have it reviewed before the next adjustment comes.

See all news and statements →

Contact our experts

Get all your questions answered, free of charge and without obligation.

Talk to an expert

Personal advice from our specialists. Response time: under 24 hours.

The PKV-Welt team: Tim and Sandra Bökemeier
Direct contact

Please answer three short questions about the person who is to be insured.

Currently insured
Occupation

Switching to private health insurance is probably not advisable for you.

From the age of 55, admission to private health insurance is often possible only with restrictions. A late switch can also mean higher premiums.

It matters to us that a switch pays off for you in the long run. That is why we do not recommend a consultation when your answers already show that the conditions are rather unfavorable.

Not sure, or want to correct your answers? Feel free to contact us. We will help you assess your situation.

 

Please choose a day

Loading free appointments

How would you like to talk?

Required field

Free of charge and without obligation. You receive a confirmation by email right away and can cancel the appointment at any time. The consultation is in English.

Your appointment is booked

The confirmation is on its way to your inbox.